“Flutter Brutter” might be the most anticipated episode of the season. Unlike a lot of other episodes, this one was announced way in advance. (It was first announced that we would see Fluttershy’s brother at last years’s MLP panel at Comic Con.) Why does this deserve hype? Interestingly, despite having six seasons, we know very little of the Mane 6’s parents/siblings/relatives. We’ve seen some of them briefly, but the show chooses not to bring them into the fold that much. (We still haven’t seen Rainbow Dash’s parents aside from a brief flashback.) There’s technically nothing wrong with this approach, and for the most part the show has done a solid job showing us bits and pieces of the ponies’ families. This week, we not only meet Fluttershy’s parents, but her younger brother as well. This was definitely a big improvement over the last installment. It’s not as great as it could have been, but still not bad.
Here’s the official description from Discovery Family:
When Fluttershy’s self-absorbed brother starts freeloading off their parents, she encourages him to move out, but he moves in with her instead, forcing Fluttershy to stand up to her brother and help him get over his fear of failure.
Fluttershy has had a criminally minimal presence this season, so another reason why this episode was hotly anticipated was that it would be her first starring role since “Scare Master” in Season 5. She isn’t a challenging character to write. What is challenging is not writing her off as some timid side character in a given story. This episode doesn’t go that route. This time we see another whole side to her: a sisterly side. But not just the nurturing sister, also as a frustrated big sister with her younger brother’s childish behavior. She literally spends almost the entire episode being annoyed. Dave Rapp in just one episode proves he can write a fantastic Fluttershy.
One of the big highlights was when Fluttershy kicked her brother out after seeing he wasn’t going to change his ways. This was powerful. Here we have her brother, family, mooching off of her. As painful as it is to do it, if someone is blatantly taking your space and completely unwilling to work when they could, well, it’s unfortunately goodbye. I was worried the episode would have her brother walk over her before she finally does something. Instead, the episode from early on establishes that Fluttershy has been dealing with this since they were fillies.
One of the problems with the episode is that it attempts to shove all this unseen backstory in less than 10 minutes. It’s similar to how Shining Armor popped up out of nowhere in the Season 2 finale. Putting that to the side, how is the character of Zephyr Breeze? Obviously, he’s written as obnoxious and annoying. Even with that in mind however, he’s a little too unbelievable sometimes. I believe the writing could have found a more realistic way to portray him without going in your face with how awful of a family member he is. Fluttershy’s parents were hard to watch sometimes too. Zephyr throwing away years of Fluttershy’s dad collection out the window, and the latter just rolling with it was too unbelievable.
A song was unexpected, but certainly welcome. Fluttershy has been part of some great songs in the past, and this one (actually her second duet with Rainbow Dash) is no exception. Unlike the last episode, the message isn’t blatantly in your face. In fact, it’s one of the show’s best. The thought of failure can be an immense deterrent to attempting to do something. But ultimately quitting is far worse than giving it your all and not succeeding. Whether it be in a video game, a job, or almost anything really, the fear of failure should be put to the side. I’m happy the episode incorporated this message into the great climax, even if Zephyr was hard to watch for the majority of it.
Overall, “Flutter Brutter” isn’t the masterpiece Fluttershy adventure I was expecting. That’s not to say it was totally disappointing however. It features one of Fluttershy’s best portrayals, which makes up for her lack of appearing this season. The concept of her having a brother the complete opposite of herself is an engaging concept, but Zephyr could have been handled better. The climax is very good. While this isn’t close to being the best Fluttershy episode, it’s still a pretty solid one.